Stanford vs. Notre Dame: Best and Worst
A look back at the best and worst from Saturday's 28-14 win over Notre Dame.
Worst Afternoon Results: After LSU took care of Arkansas on Friday, Oregon State and Auburn didn't do Stanford any favors on Saturday afternoon. The Beavers were blown out in Eugene, ending the Cardinal's Rose Bowl hopes, while Auburn got smoked in the Iron Bowl, effectively ending Stanford's BCS title game hopes. To make matters worse, the Tigers allowed a career-high 203 yards rushing to Heisman candidate Trent Richardson.
Best Display of Strength: Coby Fleener caught the first of his two touchdowns on the night around the 15-yard line and dragged Notre Dame cornerback Robert Blanton into the end zone for his ninth touchdown of the season. It was a bit like watching Magnus ver Magnusson pull a semi-truck on ESPN2 at 2 a.m., even if Blanton is only 200 pounds. The play moved Andrew Luck past John Elway for the most career passing touchdowns in Stanford history.
Worst Attire: Spotted in the Red Zone -- a student in a Kelly green Notre Dame jersey (never OK) and another student with a backwards Syracuse hat (too soon after the Cardinal's 69-63 loss to the Orange).
Best Place for a Band: Notre Dame's full band didn't travel, but there was a small contingent in the final two rows of the upper deck. Squint and you can make out a tuba.
Worst Ticket Scalper: The corner of Galvez and El Camino, two hours before kickoff. "You need tickets?" "Yeah, I need 4." "I've got 4 together for $400." "Ha. No thanks." "This a sold out game, man. You can go watch on TV." One hour later, we found 4 tickets for $40 apiece.
Best Helmets: Stanford's Nike Pro Combat uniforms and matte black helmets got all of the attention, but Notre Dame's golden domes were a sight to behold. "They look like Christmas ornaments," my friend remarked. They looked pretty awesome from the stands. As for Stanford's duds, the players loved them, which is great. I prefer the traditional uniforms, but if it's only a once a year thing, I'm cool with it.
Worst Decision: With Stanford leading 21-7 early in the fourth quarter, Luck threw incomplete to Griff Whalen on 3rd and 6 from the Notre Dame 32. Head coach David Shaw immediately trotted out Jordan Williamson for a 49-yard field goal attempt. Williamson was clutch against Cal last week in giving Stanford a two-score lead, but he missed this one wide left. Sorry, but when you have a quarterback who you've touted as a player who does things that nobody else in the nation does, and your defense has been lights out all night, I think you should show some confidence in your offense and go for it in that situation.
Best Explanation: The referee offered an eloquent explanation as to why Ty Montgomery's apparent fumble on the opening kickoff was overturned upon further review. Ty Hildenbrandt of the Solid Verbal noticed.
Worst Microphone Mishap: There was nothing soothing about the time the referee forgot to turn his microphone off before blowing his whistle to wind the clock. I think my ears are still ringing.
Best Play-Action: After Notre Dame punted with 8 minutes remaining in the game, Stanford ran 5 consecutive running plays. On the sixth play, a 2nd and 7 from the Cardinal 45, Luck went to his bread and butter, a play-action pass down the middle to a wide open Fleener. The touchdown gave Stanford a 28-7 lead, and, in my estimation, clinched the Heisman for Luck. The experts don't seem to think so.
Worst Garbage Time TD: The Irish went 87 yards on four plays in 43 seconds late in the game to cut the Stanford lead to 28-14.
Best Interceptions: Seniors Cory Gatewood and Michael Thomas had interceptions for Stanford, bringing the Cardinal's season total to 6. Stanford had 18 interceptions last year.
Worst Field Conditions: I got a closer look at Stanford's infamous turf after the game. Players didn't seem to be slipping quite as often as they did in the previous two games, but man, it's no wonder Stanford is considering artificial alternatives. I thought about taking a few pieces home to put up on eBay. Chunks of grass that Levine Toilolo slipped on could make great collector's items when he's catching TD passes in the NFL, even if they're not especially rare.
Best Preposterous Predictions: We were half right when we predicted that Luck would throw for at least four touchdowns and complete at least 75% of his passes. He finished 20-for-30 with 4 TDs and a pick. We also said Stanford would sack Tommy Rees at least 6 times. The Cardinal finished with five sacks, though some of those were against Andrew Hendrix.
Worst Preposterous Predictions: Michael Floyd finished with 92 yards receiving, which is a lot more than 40. The Cardinal didn't come close to winning by 25, but it probably could've if the playcalling wasn't so conservative in the second half. I wouldn't have preferred that Shaw go all Lane Kiffin on the Irish, but letting Luck air it out a little more in his final home game -- and with Heisman voters everywhere waiting to be wowed -- would've been nice.
Best Result: The Cardinal is 11-1 and headed to a BCS bowl for a second consecutive season. Hail, Stanford, hail.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Once a year
is okay with me also. but they did it twice this year. once with the black and now with the all “red”. I especially disliked that it was senior day and the players weren’t in traditional unis.
by farmerboy99 on Nov 29, 2025 8:28 AM PST reply actions
Worst numbers
On the Pro Combate uniforms. I wasn’t even in the upper tier and I still couldn’t see the numbers on the players. I didn’t mind the color of the uniforms (actually Cardinal!!!), but they would have been significantly better in my estimation if the numbers were all white.
by CardiGrl on Nov 29, 2025 8:33 AM PST reply actions
The numbers were terrible
It’s a wonder that the refs didn’t make them go back and change into the traditional red tops with white numbers like they did at South Carolina earlier this year.
by RedOscar on Nov 30, 2025 10:15 AM PST up reply actions
By my count, the whistle with the mic on has happened 3 times this year.
"Some of us know him as the a-hole who piled into Ray Fosse in an All-Star game (it's why Ray is the way he is folks)" - OptimistPrime
by travdog6 on Nov 29, 2025 10:13 AM PST reply actions
Terrible.
It also happened several times during the ND game.
by CardiGrl on Nov 29, 2025 10:23 AM PST up reply actions
Worst Omission from Best and Worst
Those were some amazing shoes.
/youhadtobethere
by Scott Allen on Nov 29, 2025 10:41 AM PST up reply actions
Worst officials...
I think I read that this wasn’t actually a Pac-12 crew, but wow were the officials bad for this game. We were beginning to wonder if Notre Dame had slipped them a little something extra to keep the game close. I think there was one PI call that was legit (maybe two), but the rest were laughable… and that roughing the passer call when the officials were late in blowing a play dead after a false start (and then very quiet with the whistles) was a joke.
For me, it makes the victory that much more impressive - Stanford beat Notre Dame and the refs…
by RickeySteals on Nov 29, 2025 12:29 PM PST reply actions
They were from the Big East
I believe our series with ND has Pac12 officials when we’re in South Bend, and Big East officials when they’re in Palo Alto.
by farmerboy99 on Nov 29, 2025 2:45 PM PST up reply actions
It really makes you wonder
The Big East almost literally bends over backwards to cater to Notre Dame, even in football. If the school had just joined in football, or if the Big East had made it a condition of joining with all its other sports, then the realignment fiasco of the past two years really could have been minimized substantially.
It’s no wonder Geno Auriemma blasted them last month.
by RedOscar on Nov 30, 2025 10:18 AM PST up reply actions

by Scott Allen on 









