Stanford vs. Oklahoma State: Fiesta Bowl Best and Worst
Here's a look back at the best and worst moments from Stanford's 41-38 overtime loss to Oklahoma State in the Fiesta Bowl.
Best Goodbye: Andrew Luck arguably saved his best performance for last, completing 27-of-31 passes for 347 yards and two touchdowns. After throwing an early interception, Luck was almost perfect. He was 5-for-5 on Stanford’s final drive in regulation.
Worst Night: Jordan Williamson had a nightmare of a game that he can’t forget soon enough – and maybe never will. The freshman missed three of four field goals, including a 35-yard attempt at the end of regulation that would have won the game, and a 42-yarder in overtime. Williamson made 13-of-19 field goal attempts this season, but only 2-of-7 since returning from an injury he suffered before the USC game. Keep your head up, Jordan. Next time you'll be the hero.
Best Surprise Performance: After rushing for a career-high 99 yards in last year's Orange Bowl, many figured that Jeremy Stewart's Stanford career was over. But the fifth-year senior returned and made his mark in a crowded backfield as the Cardinal’s go-to short yardage option. He was so much more in the Fiesta Bowl. Stewart rushed 3 times for 65 yards and caught a 25-yard pass from Luck on Stanford’s final drive in regulation that put the Cardinal in field goal range.
Worst Conservatism: This debate may never be resolved.
Best Preposterous Prediction: Stepfan Taylor had a preposterously good game, carrying 35 times for a career-high 177 yards. Running behind a dominant offensive line led by David DeCastro and Jonathan Martin, Taylor was phenomenal. With a new quarterback prepared to take the reins next season, Taylor could be asked to do even more. He's up to the challenge.
Worst Preposterous Prediction: Early on, limiting Justin Blackmon to 75 or fewer yards receiving seemed possible. Brandon Weeden didn’t even target the two-time Biletnikoff Award winner in the first quarter, but that changed in a hurry. Blackmon had touchdown catches of 67 and 43 yards in the second quarter and finished with 8 catches for 186 yards and 3 touchdowns. I’m not sure why Weeden bothered to look anywhere else.
Best Interception: Terrence Brown picked a good time for his first career INT, stepping in front of Weeden's first attempt for the pick.
Worst Coverage: The middle was WIDE OPEN for the Cowboys for most of the night and Weeden exploited it at will. The 28-year-old finished 29-of-42 for 399 yards and 3 touchdowns.
Best Freshman: Ty Montgomery had 7 catches for 120 yards, including a 53-yard touchdown on play-action in the first quarter. It was the first 100-yard game of Montgomery's career. It won't be the last.
Best Defensive Stand: After Geoff Meinken fumbled inside the 5-yard line with Stanford leading 28-21 in the third quarter, the Cardinal defense came up with an impressive stand. Stanford stopped Joseph Randle short of the goal line on two consecutive runs. On third down, Weeden rolled right and threw incomplete to a wide open Kye Staley in the end zone. The Cowboys settled for a field goal to cut the Cardinal lead to 28-24.
Best Drive: After Oklahoma State tied the game at 31 with 11:53 to play, Stanford put together the type of drive that has defined the Andrew Luck era. The key numbers: 13 plays, 69 yards, 7:21 off the clock, and 7 points on the scoreboard. Here's what I wrote in the game preview: The defense will make just enough plays and Luck will lead the Cardinal on a classic, 7-minute scoring drive in the fourth quarter, with a healthy dose of Stepfan Taylor and Tree's Company. Close, but the defense came up one play short...
Worst Stop: The defense, which limited Randle to 23 yards on 10 carries and played well for most of the night, couldn't come up with the stop necessary to seal the win. The Cowboys faced 4th and 3 on their game-tying drive before Weeden found Blackmon for a 21-yard gain. Randle scored on a 4-yard run three plays later.
Worst Sense of Humor: This was one Oklahoma State fan’s assessment of the LSJUMB after the game: "YOUR BAND SUCKS!" Thanks.
Best Band: LSJUMB, obviously.
Best Tackle of a Teammate: When Montgomery attempted to bring a kickoff out of the end zone from at least 5 yards deep, he was met at the goal line by Stewart, who knocked the freshman receiver flat on his butt for a touchback. The heads up play likely saved the Cardinal from awful field position, but could've been a disaster. Had Montgomery come out of the end zone before being knocked back, it would’ve been a safety, as Green Bay Packers return man Patrick Lee could tell you.
Worst Penalties: Stanford was penalized 6 times for 35 yards, while OSU was flagged once for five yards. Two of the Cardinal's penalties were especially costly. With Stanford leading 28-24, Griff Whalen was called for holding on a 3rd and 16 pass play to Montgomery that went for a first down. In overtime, Levine Toilolo was whistled for a false start after Taylor rushed for 5 yards on first down.
Best Pass: The play-action strike to Montgomery was beautiful, but Luck's 20-yard pass to Whalen on 3rd and 14 late in the fourth quarter was what makes him so special. Luck rolled right, looked off at least two other options before finding Whalen, directing him to a spot, and throwing a perfect pass along the right sidline. Stanford scored on the drive to take a 38-31 lead. Whalen finished with 7 catches for 85 yards.
Best Tackle of an Opponent: It didn't matter in the end -- except to some unlucky gamblers -- but Delano Howell chased down Colton Chelf at the half-yard line in overtime to keep Stanford's slim hopes alive.
Best Moment: I didn’t stick around to watch the postgame ceremony, but I got a little choked up watching this video of Mike Gundy hand the Fiesta Bowl trophy to Shelley Budke, the wife of former OSU women's basketball coach Kurt Budke, who died in a plane crash along with assistant coach Miranda Serna earlier this season.
Worst Formation: The Wildcat was completely ineffective against the Cowboys. Tyler Gaffney, who took two direct snaps in the formation, finished with four carries for four yards.
Best Fan Support: Stanford fans may have been outnumbered in Glendale, but they were loud and proud.
Best Postgame Meal: In-n-Out near the stadium. Neapolitan shakes taste better after wins, but they're pretty good after losses, too.
Worst Wait: It’ll be 8 months before Stanford can return to the win column and start to erase this bitter feeling.
Best Season: The loss was heartbreaking, but it doesn't overshadow another amazing season. Hats off to David Shaw, his staff, and all the players. The future remains bright for Stanford football.
9 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
the band
I really hope you aren’t serious about the Stanford band. I was embarrassed by the band. There are 2 reasons OkSt fans said the band sucks.
1) The band compared Oklahoma women to livestock in their song.
2) Throughout the entire trophy presentation for OkSt, the band played loud music.
Talk about classless. As for point #1, you can poke fun at another school without doing something like comparing the women of an entire state with livestock. Show a real sense of humor without resorting to petty insults.
As for point #2, this is just flat out unacceptable. Show some dignity in losing. I know I would be livid if the OkSt band tried to crash our victory celebration that we had just earned. At one point, during Mike Gundy’s victory speech, he had to ask the band to stop playing.
The band showed what a bunch of classless losers that they are, and it’s absolutely pathetic. Don’t try to defend their inconsiderate and ignorant actions.
by stflory on Jan 4, 2026 12:22 PM PST reply actions
Your complaints are heard
But they’ve been echoed by nearly every opponent that we’ve ever played, so no your complaints hold no merit, at least not with many alums and fans. It’s what they do, and its what we like.
** Rule of Tree ** Pounding the Rock ** Battle of Cali ** Fear the Fin ** Athletics Nation ** Niners Nation **
by RedOscar on Jan 4, 2026 1:04 PM PST up reply actions
So you’re saying if you’re an asshole all the time, and that’s your “thing” then it becomes ok?
If the OkSt band did the same thing while David Shaw was giving his victory speech (had we won) I’m sure you would be saying the OkSt band showed no class and was a bunch of jerks. It’s a 2-way street, and you should always show respect for your opponent.
As for the consensus among alums and fans, I know my entire group of friends (around 15 of us from class of ’10) all HATE the band, and have been embarrassed by them from day 1. And I ran into over 10 Stanford alums after the game (ranging in age from 30 to 60) who all said they were writing letters to Bowlsby and Hennessey saying they were embarrassed by the way our band treated the opposition.
Trying to rain on another school’s celebration is classless, and I think you would be hard pressed to find alums/students who say they are proud that the Stanford band played music all throughout OkSt’s victory ceremony.
by stflory on Jan 4, 2026 2:00 PM PST up reply actions
I honestly had no idea about your second point
As I said, I left before the postgame ceremony. I agree that’s pretty classless. Misses the part about them comparing women to livestock too. Figured the vitriol stemmed from the fact that they’re not like every other band. Apologies.
by Scott Allen on Jan 4, 2026 2:52 PM PST via iPhone app up reply actions
Just saying, after the win, OSU fans called out “nerds” to departing Stanford fans.
by smartazjb0y on Jan 4, 2026 1:23 PM PST up reply actions
Sigh...
… the Stanford band is not meant to be taken seriously. The joke as I remember it was that it seemed like the song Oklahoma compared Oklahoma women to livestock, and that didn’t seem right. Within the context of the overall show, I thought it was pretty funny. Like many classic songs, when you parse the words from the musical, they do seem a little ridiculous…
The thing you have to keep in mind about the Stanford band is that they start with the premise that college bands are generally pointless and silly, so why not have fun with the whole thing? Anyone who takes themselves or their school too seriously could easily find ways to be offended, but good grief you’d really have to work at it to be offended by what the Stanford band did this time.
I also left before the post game ceremony, and if that’s what the band did it was wrong. There was plenty of classlessness to go around though… The OSU band played right on through the snap when Stanford was on offense. Maybe that’s considered an acceptable practice in the Big 12, but even if it is, it seems pretty like pretty poor sportsmanship to me. No band that I’ve seen in the Pac-10/12 does that. It is possible I just haven’t seen enough other school bands, but the Stanford band certainly makes every effort to avoid doing that…
by RickeySteals on Jan 5, 2026 12:20 AM PST up reply actions
Scott's "Worst Sense of Humor" still holds true, despite stflory's criticism
I agree, Rickey. The band makes fun of itself and of others because of the premise that all college bands are silly. Case in point? The OSU band. Despite their size, I could barely hear anything they were playing. When I could faintly hear the OSU band, they were spewing something that did not ring familiar to me at all. In other words, were they playing songs? They took themselves so seriously, yet their final product was well below the signature collegiate bands like USC (yes, it pains me to admit that). Ultimately, they just looked silly and pointless. Why not have some fun if you know you’re going to be terrible? That’s exactly what the LSJUMB does.
My real theory about why most Stanford alums seem to revere the LSJUMB is that Stanford’s never been a “real” football school, so the LSJUMB is the only thing we used to have to hold onto during games. Now that Stanford football is on the map, I think students and younger alums think that the LSJUMB should be conforming to a marching band to match other schools. I strongly disagree. The LSJUMB is one of those uniquely Stanford entities, created by a culture that encourages individuality and entreprenuership. I hope that never changes.
I’ll also note that younger alums and current students should be careful what they wish for. When I was in school, there was a huge backlash against the Yell Leaders for their antics and ultimately the Athletic Department got rid of them. Ironically, I really miss them. There are no creative cheers that are so characteristic of Stanford’s quirkiness now, and no one to lead cheers of any kind. I would hope that students embrace the unique nature of the LSJUMB. Of course, playing through the awards ceremony is classless, but who ever called the LSJUMB classy?
by CardiGrl on Jan 5, 2026 8:05 AM PST up reply actions

by Scott Allen on 








