Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Shutdown Fullback: The World's Only College Football Show

Stanford vs. Virginia Tech Orange Bowl: Best and Worst

I'll address the Jim Harbaugh speculation (his bro says Michigan is out) and Andrew Luck's future later tonight and in the coming days, but first I'll honor Harbaugh's wishes and "respect the game" with this look back at the best and worst from Monday's Orange Bowl.

Best Tailgate: Toby the Van. Brian, Wade, and Toby were terrific hosts in the shadow of Sun Life Stadium. Stanford revelers came for the food and drink and stayed for this entertaining Hokie fan. I didn't attend, but I hear the alumni tailgate was a good time.

Best Performance, Expected Edition: Andrew Luck, who was a masterful 18-for-23 for 287 yards and four touchdowns. He looked a little off early in the game and he got away with a bad decision that should have been Jayron Hosley's second interception, but he settled down and made some incredible throws.

Best Performance, Unexpected Edition: Coby Fleener, who caught six passes for 173 yards and three touchdowns. Honorable mention: Jeremy Stewart.

Star-divide

Best Use of Foam: A number of fans had tree-shaped foam fingers, which I was told were given away at Sunday night's pep rally. Had I known that, I would've arrived a day earlier.

Worst Use of Foam: Taco Bell was giving away taco-shaped hats and samples (of food, not foam) inside the Game Day Fan Zone.

Best Houdini Act: Tyrod Taylor, whose touchdown pass to David Wilson in the second quarter was one of the best plays you'll ever see. Taylor was sacked eight times, but it really felt like it should've been 15. It was torturous to watch him wiggle his way out of trouble in the first half. The reaction from Stanford fans in the stadium went something like this: "Oh! Yes! Get him! GET HIM! No! GET HIM!!!!!!! NOOOOO. Crap." From the upper deck, Taylor looked like Pac-Man with an endless supply of power pellets dodging ghosts up and down the field.

Best Second Half Adjustment: Vic Fangio's Stanford defense, which shut out the Hokies after halftime. Shayne Skov led the way with 12 tackles and three sacks.

Best Use of Hands: Delano Howell, who stepped in front of Jarrett Boykin to intercept Taylor at the Stanford 3-yard line with the Cardinal leading 19-12 in the third quarter. Taylor had floated a 42-yard pass to Danny Coale just over the outstretched arm of a leaping Chase Thomas earlier in the drive and seemed poised to lead the Hokies for the tying score.

Worst Use of Hands: Virginia Tech fan who flipped off the videoboard camera. On the whole, Hokies fans I met in Miami were very nice.

Best 2-Play Drive: Stanford, which went 97 yards in 29 seconds after Howell's interception to increase its lead to 14. Stepfan Taylor broke off a 56-yard run before Luck found Fleener wide open down the middle for his first touchdown of the game.

Best 7-Yard Run: James McGillicuddy, the sixth-year senior lineman and fan favorite, who ran off the field to some of the loudest cheers of the night after his first and only career carry.

Worst Reflex: Derek Hall, who caught Luck's batted pass in the back of the end zone for a safety in the first quarter.

Best "Musical" Act: The one, the only, the truly incomparable Leland Stanford Junior University Marching Band. The LSJUMB mocked LeBron James' "Decision" in an on-field performance before the game. It also played near Toby the Van on its way to the Fan Zone.

Worst Special Teams: Nate Whitaker missed two extra points and Drew Terrell fielded a punt inside his own 5-yard line. In the end, it didn't matter. Both players had very good seasons.

Worst Surprise: Three times, the game official forgot to turn off his microphone before blowing his whistle after announcing a penalty call. As my friend remarked, "I think my ears are bleeding." Cardinal red, of course.

Best Fans: There were a lot of opportunities to cheer, and cheer the Cardinal fans did.

Best Chant: THANK YOU SEN-IORS! It was short-lived, and it was drowned out by the chants of STAY! HARBAUGH! STAY! and ONE MORE YEAR!, but it was the most fitting.

Best Celebration: Oranges and smiles all around.

Best Postgame Text Message: From a friend and Hokies fan, who, like me, is a suffering Redskins fan. "So um...Stanford is awesome at football and I want andrew luck to be a redskin. Holy crap." (Washington Post sports blogger Dan Steinberg's Best-Worst lists inspired this post.)

 

Worst Suspense: A group of Stanford fans watch the postgame press conference on a TV outside of Sun Life Stadium. Harbaugh and Luck refused to address their future plans

Best Seatmate: On the flight home, I sat next to a former Western Kentucky football player who played for Jack Harbaugh. He remembered Jack as an excitable guy.

Tweet Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Rule Of Tree

Predicting Stanford's 2012 Football Season (in January)

Jan 2012 by Scott Allen - 9 comments

Stanford vs. Oklahoma State: Fiesta Bowl Best and Worst

Jan 2012 by Scott Allen - 9 comments

Card Clicks: Stanford Players Rally Around Williamson

Jan 2012 by Scott Allen - 3 comments

David Shaw's Conservatism Costs Stanford in Fiesta Bowl

Jan 2012 by Scott Allen - 22 comments

2012 Fiesta Bowl Prediction: Stanford vs. Oklahoma State

Jan 2012 by Scott Allen - 3 comments

Comments

Display:

Best Orange Bowl Round-Up

This blog post.

Nice one, Scott!

by CardiGrl on Jan 4, 2026 6:13 PM PST reply actions  

Foam trees

They were given to the first 1000 people at Maples for the game Sunday night. Remarkably, I got there 45 minutes before tipoff and they were out of them “for a good while” when I asked about them.

by RedOscar on Jan 4, 2026 6:22 PM PST via mobile reply actions  

Interesting

I hope the athletic department ordered a lot of them. I still have a few foam axes from Big Game my freshman year.

by Scott Allen on Jan 4, 2026 6:47 PM PST up reply actions  

Foam Trees and Axes

Could someone post a picture of these?

by jterry94 on Jan 4, 2026 9:28 PM PST up reply actions  

The axes are aplenty, but I can’t seem to find a picture of one on the intertubes right now (I have one from a few years ago as well somewhere in my apartment).

The trees are shaped as the Palo Alto, all red, and have a little message in the center that says something like “Go Stanford!” and Wells Fargo or something on there in white. They sounded pretty blech when they were announced last week, but having actually seen them, I can see now why they were so popular.

by RedOscar on Jan 5, 2026 11:15 AM PST up reply actions  

best hurdle

fleener’s hurdle was great.

Also, that VT fan appears to be modeling his look after Shayne Skov. Needs more warpaint though.

by brooksengr on Jan 4, 2026 8:59 PM PST reply actions  

Best Face Save

Harbaugh, after clearly arguing on field that Tyrod Taylor had stepped out of bounds on his houdini TD pass, claims in press conference that he told Taylor, “Yes, you were in bounds, and that was a heck of a play, young man.”

It's orange inside

by TheAntiBork on Jan 5, 2026 10:30 AM PST reply actions  

It actually was confirmed by TT

I don’t remember if it was Purdy or Wilner or Fitzgerald, but one of the writers talked about how ESPN made it look like TT and Harbaugh were arguing with each other after that VT touchdown, but both of them confirmed after the game that Taylor was asking Harbaugh if he was in, and Harbaugh yelled, “Yes, you were in bounds…”

Now before that, when TT was actually throwing the ball, Harbaugh actually did point to Taylor’s feet and the sideline, but I guess he realized he was in-bounds for the throw.

by RedOscar on Jan 5, 2026 11:07 AM PST up reply actions  

Also, Skov should get honorable mention in one of the “best performance” categories, probably more “expected” than “unexpected”.

It's orange inside

by TheAntiBork on Jan 5, 2026 10:33 AM PST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Stanford Cardinal.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Q and A with Cal Golden Blogs, Part I
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Seniors Remain Unbeaten at Home
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Seniors Get Win Over Utah
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Keeps Home Streak Alive by Beating Colorado
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Crushes Oregon State
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Beats UCLA in Second Half
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB Beats USC, Gets No Respect
Wsilogo_small
Stanford WBB’s Second Pac-12 Win in the Desert
Wsilogo_small
Defense Key in 62-49 Stanford WBB win over ASU
Wsilogo_small
Exciting Finish to Stanford-Cal WBB game

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Tree_small Scott Allen

Authors

RedOscar